Issue date: 10/12/07 Section: News
Stetson Departure | Experts say honesty the best policy for Stetson
In high-level departures, candidness may be in universities' best interests
Anthony Campisi
The University's handling of the departure of former Dean of Admissions Lee Stetson may be doing Penn more harm than good, crisis-management experts say.
Ever since Stetson announced his resignation at the beginning of the semester, both he and Penn officials have repeatedly refused to give an explanation of the departure.
Penn President Amy Gutmann has only said it was in the "best interests" of both Stetson and the University.
But several public-relations experts say that, in cases like this, the best defense against bad publicity is openness and honesty.
"The rule in any kind of issue that becomes a crisis is that you try to tell as much a you can as often as you can," said Anne Klein, president of Anne Klein Communications Group Inc.
Klein, who handles crisis management for her clients, said being open about negative news is usually the best way to defuse a situation because mystery tends to make things worse.
"The problem is that sometimes [refusal to comment] becomes the story," she said.
Scott Barkett, senior vice president of crisis management for public relations firm Dix & Eaton, agreed.
"When something has gone wrong, the quickest and simplest way to get it behind you is to disclose what you know, admit what went wrong and talk about what your next steps are," he said.
Barkett also cautioned that organizations that avoid this generally accepted crisis-management tactic "expose [themselves] to the possibility of creating a larger story."
The upshot of this open approach can be seen in the departure of Marilee Jones, former admissions dean for the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
When MIT discovered that Jones had falsified parts of her resume, both she and the school issued statements explaining why she was leaving.
2008 Woodie Awards


Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 23
Alum
posted 10/12/07 @ 9:59 AM EST
Part of Lori Doyle's job is to be a spin doctor, but she can't believe anyone is swallowing the load of crap she's shoveling here. Of course senior executives of companies and universities depart regularly. (Continued…)
Another Alum
posted 10/12/07 @ 12:05 PM EST
Well put, Alum! I agree completely.
And congratulations to the DP for keeping this a front-page story.
A lot of alumni will be on campus next weekend for Homecoming and the big capital campaign kickoff, and they need to be asking some hard questions about this. (Continued…)
Bill Wh '68
posted 10/12/07 @ 12:59 PM EST
Enough already with the conspiracy theories. He left. He's not coming back. End of story. Let's move on.
He did an excellent job for 29 years, but he is not the only reason Penn has risen to where it is. (Continued…)
Steve Maczko
posted 10/12/07 @ 1:18 PM EST
I too think the DP is doing a great job here.
My question is how many others, who might not have had Dean Stetson's prominence, have been purged over the past several years. (Continued…)
Alumna
posted 10/12/07 @ 1:21 PM EST
Personnel matters are routinely confidential. What is so hard to grasp about that? Clearly there was an incident of some sort and agreement that it was in both parties' best interest for it not to become public. (Continued…)
InsideView...
posted 10/12/07 @ 2:37 PM EST
Ditto - Transparency is "suppose" to be one of the core values of Penn and is part of the office of Development and Alumni Relations core values. It is sadly a value rarely practiced. (Continued…)
InsideView...
posted 10/12/07 @ 2:39 PM EST
Ditto - Transparency is "suppose" to be one of the core values of Penn and is part of the office of Development and Alumni Relations core values. It is sadly a value rarely practiced. (Continued…)
Enough Already
posted 10/12/07 @ 2:44 PM EST
Let it GGOOOOOOOOO!
If there are parties involved DIRECTLY (Stetson, PENN, one or numerous offended people) in something "bad," they aren't talkin'. (Continued…)
Enough Already
posted 10/12/07 @ 8:21 PM EST
Alum...In answer to your reply, "If everybody had your attitude back in 1941, we would be speaking german and japanese now. There is clearly a stench of misconduct and people should be told the truth. (Continued…)
Enough Already
posted 10/12/07 @ 8:33 PM EST
And another thing....Those of you who have graduated from Penn in the last 25 years?...
Stetson's ARRIVAL obviously impacted, in some way, your ability to call yourselves "Alum. (Continued…)
Post a Comment